Blogs

Why Generic Platforms Miss the Distribution Chain

Why Generic Platforms Miss the Distribution Chain

Most compliance management software is built for compliance that happens inside your own four walls. Insurance compliance largely happens in someone else’s. That single structural fact is why so many implementations end up as an expensive record of work done elsewhere, rather than a system that actually holds your risk. This piece sets out what the category actually contains, the four capabilities insurance compliance genuinely requires, an honest read on spreadsheets versus platforms, and how to make oversight evidenceable without adding headcount.

Your Compliance Obligation Sits Where Your Activity Does Not

In its insurance multi-firm review of outcomes monitoring under the Consumer Duty), the FCA found that firms were often focused on process completion rather than actual customer outcomes, and that some board and committee reporting contained limited insight into whether good outcomes were genuinely being delivered. That finding is worth sitting with. It was not a gap in effort. Every firm in the review was doing something. It was a gap in evidence.

That gap has a structural cause, and it is the one most compliance software ignores. A manufacturer’s compliance platform tracks incidents, training and audits inside its own operation, because that is where its compliance activity happens. Your regulatory exposure runs through appointed representatives, coverholders, MGAs, third-party administrators and the brokers you trade with. The activity you have to evidence is performed by people you do not employ, using systems you do not control. A platform built for internal process cannot see any of that, however well it handles the parts it can see.

This is not a niche complaint about a mismatched feature set. It is the defining fact of insurance compliance, and it means the question to ask any platform is not “does it manage compliance” but “whose compliance does it manage”. A firm can run a flawless internal attestation programme and still have no reliable answer to whether a coverholder’s regulatory permissions still cover what it is doing this quarter. Those are two different jobs, and most of the market only sells one of them.

The pressure to close that gap is about to become a filing deadline rather than a good idea. On 18 March 2026 the FCA published final rules and guidance on operational incident and material third party reporting, PS26/2, with finalised guidance in FG26/4. From 18 March 2027, in-scope firms must maintain a register of material third party arrangements, notify new arrangements and significant changes, and submit that register annually. Materiality is judged on the consequence of failure rather than contract value, so do not assume your current supplier list tells you who is in scope. Confirm it.

The rest of this piece works through what that means in practice: what compliance management software actually covers today, the four things insurance compliance specifically requires that generic platforms do not provide, an honest comparison between spreadsheets and platforms, and how to close the evidence gap without expanding the compliance team.

What the Category Actually Contains

Search “compliance management software” and the market you find splits into three groups, and it is worth being straight with yourself about which one you are looking at. There are health, safety and environmental platforms, built around incident logging, site risk and permits to work. There are horizontal GRC suites, built for policy attestation, controls testing and internal audit across a corporate function. And there are information security compliance tools, built to collect the evidence a company needs to pass SOC 2 or ISO 27001.

Each of these does something genuinely well, and your firm may legitimately need one alongside whatever handles counterparty compliance. HSEQ platforms are the right tool for incidents and site risk. GRC suites are the right tool for a policy library, control testing and issue tracking across internal functions. Infosec tools are the right tool for certification evidence.

None of them holds a counterparty. None of them knows what a delegated authority scope covers, whether a TOBA is current, whether an entity’s regulatory permissions still match what it is actually doing, or whether an ultimate beneficial owner changed last month. That is not a minor gap in an otherwise complete product. For an insurance distribution chain, it is the whole job.

The practical result is familiar to anyone who has bought one of these platforms and then watched what actually happened next. The firm ends up with a good, well-implemented system for the compliance it controls directly, and a spreadsheet running alongside it for the compliance that actually creates the firm’s regulatory exposure. The spreadsheet is not a stopgap. It has quietly become the real system of record for the part of the business the FCA cares about most.

None of this means the category is badly built. It means it was built for a different shape of business, one where compliance is a set of internal controls a firm can fully own and audit end to end. A broker, MGA or carrier operating through a distribution chain does not have that luxury. The obligation is yours. The primary source of the evidence is not.

The Four Things Insurance Compliance Software Has To Do

1. Hold one authoritative record of every counterparty. Not a list per team. Underwriting knows its coverholders. Operations knows its TPAs. Finance knows its suppliers. No one holds the single consolidated view the FCA will expect firms to be able to produce from 2027. The record has to carry function, materiality, internal owner, permissions, TOBA status and review cadence, in one place, not reconstructed from three inboxes when someone asks for it.

2. Monitor continuously, because the facts change between reviews. Sanctions and PEP status, ownership and UBO structure, financial standing, regulatory permissions and adverse media do not wait for your review cycle. An annual refresh means the firm is confident about a position that may have changed eleven months ago, on a counterparty it has been trading with the whole time.

3. Collect from the counterparty, not just about them. This is the capability generic platforms lack entirely, because it assumes an external party who will not automatically comply. Insurance compliance requires you to request documents and management information from partners repeatedly, and to prove when you asked, what arrived, and what you did about the gap if it did not. Email chains and shared drives are where this obligation quietly fails, because nobody owns the follow-up once the request has gone out.

4. Produce evidence as a by-product of the work. The real test of any platform is whether the audit trail exists because the work happened inside the system, or whether someone has to reconstruct it after the fact when a supervisor or capacity provider asks. This is exactly the FCA’s finding on process completion versus outcomes. Recording that a review took place is not the same as showing what it found, and what changed because of it.

Spreadsheets, Platforms, and the Honest Middle

Give spreadsheets their due before moving past them. They survive in this market because they are flexible, free at the point of use, and shaped exactly to how a firm actually works, without anyone having to ask a vendor for a change request. A well-built tracker, maintained by someone who knows the book, can hold a surprising amount of complexity. Do not open this argument by calling spreadsheets a problem, because for a lot of firms they were, for a long time, the right answer.

Where they stop working is a question of scale, not sophistication. The point of failure is not the spreadsheet itself. It is the number of counterparties multiplied by the number of attributes that change without telling you. One person can hold fifty relationships in their head, including who owns what and when it is due for review. No one holds four hundred, and the firms feeling this pressure hardest are usually the ones that have grown fastest.

That growth is real and measurable. According to the Insurance DataLab and MGAA MGA Performance Report 2026, aggregate MGA revenues grew 8.0% to £1.2 billion over the past year, while revenue per employee rose 12.2% to £203,000, with staff costs holding at 40.0% of revenue. Read plainly, the market is getting more output per head almost everywhere. Compliance oversight of the distribution chain is one of the few functions where that has not happened, because the tools most firms use for it do not scale the way the rest of the business has.

REG’s research points to the same gap from the inside. Around 70% of the industry still relies on outdated and fragmented processes for reviewing and managing trading partners, and almost 66% of insurance leaders feel regulatory requirements hinder initiating new business relationships. Standardising due diligence across a broker or binder panel is exactly where REG Network is built to sit, replacing the version where five people each hold a partial view of the same panel. It is worth reading alongside a wider look at what fragmented, spreadsheet-based oversight actually costs a firm once it is put next to the growth numbers above.

Closing the Evidence Gap Without Adding Headcount

Start with the resourcing reality, because it is the actual objection underneath most of this. The four controls set out above are not deliverable by hand, on a spreadsheet, by a compliance function of two or three people overseeing a partner population in the hundreds. That is not a criticism of the team. It is arithmetic. Continuous monitoring, structured collection, and evidence that exists as a by-product of the work all require something other than a person remembering to check.

This is where a platform earns its place, and where REG’s products are built specifically for this problem rather than adapted from a generic one. A single source of truth for counterparty data, configurable and repeatable risk assessment, continuous screening across AML, KYB, KYC, PEPs and sanctions, and a secure exchange for the documents and management information you need from partners, not just about them. REG Risk 365 monitors more than 10,000 counterparty data changes a month across more than 50 data sources, and over 300 insurance firms already run their counterparty oversight through REG Network, with document and data exchange handled through REG Exchanges).

The operational-efficiency argument here is not “less admin”. It is that the same team can hold a larger panel to the same standard, and can answer an oversight question in minutes rather than assembling it from three systems over a fortnight. That difference is the one that shows up when a capacity provider, a regulator, or your own board asks for evidence with no notice.

For a firm weighing whether the disruption of moving off a spreadsheet is worth it, that is the question to hold onto. Not whether the new system is more sophisticated, but whether it lets the existing team cover more ground, with less reconstruction work, at the exact moment someone outside the firm asks to see it.

There is one more thing worth saying plainly, because it is where most implementations actually succeed or fail. The platforms that get adopted are the ones that sit inside the workflow the team already has, not alongside it. A system that requires someone to remember to update it separately will be out of date within a quarter, whatever it promised at the sales stage. The record has to update because someone onboarded a broker, not because someone remembered to log it afterwards.

Compliance management software, as a category, is built for compliance that happens inside one organisation. Insurance compliance happens across a chain: the obligation sits with you, but the activity sits with a partner you do not employ. That is why the deciding capability is not policy libraries or attestation workflows. It is whether the platform can hold, monitor and collect from a counterparty, and turn that work into evidence without anyone having to reconstruct it later.

The timeline for closing this gap is no longer indefinite. From March 2027, your firm’s own account of its material third parties becomes a filed, dated document, and the FCA has already said, in plain terms, that it wants evidence of outcomes rather than evidence of process. Both of those apply whether or not the firm feels ready.

Start by consolidating the counterparty record into one place. Move monitoring from periodic to continuous. Then judge any platform, including REG’s, on a single question: does it produce evidence as a by-product of the work, or does someone still have to go and build it when they are asked.

This article was published by:

Article author

Nathan Banfield, Head of Customer Success at REG Technologies

Nathan Banfield

Head of Customer Success

Nathan Banfield is the Head of Customer Success at REG Technologies. Nathan is passionate about bringing the best service to our customers and strives to help them run their business Faster, Smarter, Safer.

View LinkedIn profile

See how The REG Network can help you

Talk to one of our experts to start streamlining your processes